Mongolia Investment Climate At The Moment: Uh-Oh

I recently attended the Mongolia Investment Summit in Hong Kong on October 30 & 31, 2012. The opening keynote speech by Christopher de Gruben of Make A Difference Investment Solutions was titled The Mongolian Tango. In it Mr. de Gruben suggested that the dictionary definition of Dutch Disease would one day be renamed Mongolian Disease. The outlook for foreigners investing in the country became more dour from there, both inside the convention hall, and even more so in the conversations that took place outside the hall in the corridors.

This article will end on a note of reasons for long-term optimism about Mongolia, but the near-term outlook is not good. If currently invested in Mongolian holdings, evaluate your positions on an individual basis. I stand by my recent article on the three safest companies to hold at this time, albeit with less confidence in the near-term: Mongolian Mining Corporation (MOGLF.PK), Mongolia Growth Group (MNGGF.PK) and Mongolia Blue Wolf Holdings (MNGLU). Additionally, for those who are interested in Turquoise Hill Resources (TRQ), be advised that multiple ex-pat professionals who live in Mongolia are saying off-the-record that they would be short Turquoise Hill at this time to hedge their exposure to Mongolia.

The lawyer

The strongest presentation given at the Mongolia Investment Summit on the problems that the Strategic Entities Foreign Investment Law [SEFIL] passed in May 2012 have created came from international attorney James Liotta. You can read through his power point presentation yourself, so below are selected notes I wrote from his presentation:

- The law effects all resources, not just mining. Could be fishing, agriculture, banking, anything.

- Also, this law impacts any company supplying goods or services to an identified strategic Mongolian entity.

- Every foreign entity with greater than a 5% holding in a company doing any business in Mongolia must be regulated by the Foreign Investment Regulations and Registration Department [FIRRD] within six months of the law's passing (that is this week). [The law was passed May 17, 2012 (English begins on 2nd page of the link). There are questions as to whether 6 months from the date of the law is November 17th, or 180 days from the law's passing which would be Monday, November 12th.]

- The law's taxation laws extend to investments held both onshore and off-shore.

- Any perceived violation of SEFIL can invalidate licenses (e.g. mining licenses).

- There is a total lack of legal clarity in the law as to: who is impacted, what is strategic, or what is a resource.

- The law may regulate foreign transactions. It is unclear.

- Approval of larger holdings in investments can take up to 125 days under SEFIL. This would be mainly for single foreign holders holding over 33.33% of an entity that need extensive government approval.

- On the other hand, three category 1 investors (see presentation) could each hold 33.32% of an entity and not trigger the need for any government approval.

- And, Mr. Liotta said, he personally "could name 18 transactions cancelled because of this law" since May 2012.

History

Pausing from this negative outlook, Dr. Graeme Hancock, Chief Operating Officer of Erdenes Tavan Tolgoi, the largest coal mine in the country (which is state-owned), has a distinct and incisive perspective on Mongolia as he was previously head of the World Bank in the country for 5 years. Dr. Hancock pointed out that a foreign investment law such as SEFIL was indeed needed for a long time going back to 2005.

Speaking after Mr. Liotta on the same panel, Dr. Hancock recounted the story of the British company Soco (SOCLF.PK) which discovered petroleum in Mongolia and then sold its petroleum interests in Mongolia to PetroChina (PTR) in April 2005, "while the [Mongolian] government watched in horror unable to do anything to protect its strategic interests." He added that we should remember "most other countries have laws to protect against foreign investment" although "[SEFIL] needs a thorough rethink to figure out how to encourage good foreign investing while protecting national interests."

For those who don't know, SEFIL was hastily passed in May 2012 primarily to block Chinese company Chalco (ACH) from buying two coal producing companies in Mongolia.

Rio Tinto says

Cameron McRae's presentation followed the panel on which were Mr. Liotta and Dr. Hancock. Mr. McRae is Rio Tinto's Mongolia country manager, and President & CEO of Oyu Tolgoi, the project owned 66% by Turquoise Hill which is in turn 51% owned by Rio Tinto (RIO). In his words, Oyu Tolgoi "will supply 25% of the copper in Asia and be a top 5 copper mine" in the world when it reaches full production. His presentation on The Promise Of Oyu Tolgoi points out that by 2020 "80% of the wealth will come from [the] underground" mining (and 20% from open-pit operations). There is much work and capital investment that still needs to be made to realize this operation.

(Turquoise Hill is 51% owned by Rio Tinto.)

There is a page in Mr. McRae's presentation simply titled, "The Importance Of A Committed World-Class Partner." If you think Turquoise Hill is a good investment right now, consider this context for his comments that followed while on this subject.

Three contextual facts

- There is legislation in parliament currently to raise royalty taxes on mines, including Oyu Tolgoi, which contravene Turquoise Hill's agreements with the government from 2009 (Turquoise Hill was called Ivanhoe Mines at that time). This is no small affair with the tax being able to rise up to 20% compared to the Oyu Tolgoi Investment Agreement pegging the tax at 5%. Every cost and tax goes into a mine's business model to determine how much of the resources are worth getting out of the ground and at what profit. Changing this tax is not only contrary to then Ivanhoe's and the government of Mongolia's agreements, but also will require Turquoise Hill to redo its report on profitability, including its NI43-101 reporting.

- There is legislation going through Mongolia's parliament voiding Mongolia's tax treaty with the Netherlands where Turquoise Hill is domiciled (at link, go down to "subsidiaries" and see "Turquoise Hill Netherlands Cooperative"). There are also some major foreign investors domiciled in Luxembourg, Kuwait, and the United Arab Emirates, the three other countries included in this legislation which Ernst & Young details in the linked article. If Mongolia's aim is to irritate its largest foreign investors, the government is on target.

- The new Minister of Mining in Mongolia has publicly stated that he will resign if he does not succeed in renegotiating the agreement for Oyu Tolgoi and increasing the government's stake in the mine from 34% to 50%.

Thus Mr. McRae said at the investment summit

While recent news of an agreement with the Chinese to supply power to Oyu Tolgoi operations briefly boosted Turquoise Hill's share price, the situation between Oyu Tolgoi and the government remains contentious. My notes from Mr. McRae's presentation of October 30, 2012, include:

- Oyu Tolgoi needs assurances and support from the government to proceed.

- 75% of the next few years production is already sold to Chinese smelters.

- He believes Mongolia's government will finish the work it needs to, in order to complete the investment climate needed for investment and development.

- Yet, (the government should remember that) the agreement with Oyu Tolgoi kicked off Mongolia's economic development.

- Foreign investors are watching the unresolved issues between Oyu Tolgoi and the government as a signal to them of whether Mongolia is a good place to invest.

- The Mongolian government is contending that promises and agreements can be kept and changed at the same time, and this is not possible.

- Investors are looking for a message that the government of Mongolia will keep its promises to investors.

Off the record

I have been troubled by what to do with information that was said in the hallways outside of the conference, and at evening parties. It is against my policy to quote people off the record or whom are drunk. It is also against my policy to put investors in harm's way.

Below are some things I heard that I will relate in the most anonymous way possible to protect those who said it.

Rio Tinto is 51% owner of Turquoise Hill which in turn owns 66% of Oyu Tolgoi.

Idle, and often ridiculous, speculations people say in private to amuse each other at meals and parties:

- The government of Mongolia intentionally drives down the price of Turquoise Hill with their public tactics so members of the government or their cronies can buy more shares cheaply.

- Rio Tinto actually promotes the negative news out of Mongolia in the media so they can buy shares formerly of Ivanhoe and now Turquoise Hill cheaply.

- Robert Friedland, former CEO of Ivanhoe/Turquoise Hill, is still pulling the strings and promotes the negative news about Oyu Tolgoi so he can buy more shares cheaply.

- And, regarding the Government of Mongolia's intent to issue $1.5 billion in bonds internationally toward infrastructure development, people are gossiping that Rio Tinto will behind closed doors tell all banks that if they sell those bonds, Rio Tinto will cease doing business with them, until such time as the government of Mongolia shows it will honor the original Oyu Tolgoi investment agreements.

Although entertaining at a party, I don't believe any of these statements to be true. However, I mention them here to provide a sense of the investment climate in Mongolia and just how crazy tall tales about what is going on with Oyu Tolgoi have become (for the benefit of Turquoise Hill investors).

That said, the next item is something people said off the record I believe is true.

Off the record still, a banking crisis

There was one thing I heard from six different people who live and work in Mongolia for which I could not find a single person that would disagree. One or more banks in Mongolia is on the verge of collapse. All believe at least one bank will collapse within the next six months due to a decline in foreign investment activity, and the inability of businesses to repay loans to the banks (businesses which rely on foreign investment for their profits), since the passing of SEFIL. No one will say that this problem exists on the record.

Some people who told me about the looming banking crisis provided particular details about specific situations the banks are in, and sometimes specific banks. Other people who I went to as people who would be in positions to know simply responded with a grimace that it was indeed likely one or more local banks in Mongolia will collapse in the next six months.

This has me worried. There is no FDIC insurance in Mongolia. If a bank goes under, people with their money at that bank may never see those funds again. As I write this, I realize I may create a run on the banks that makes matters worse when this article circulates in Mongolia. However, if I don't write this, I put people at risk simply because not one of those six people is willing to state on the record that they believe one or more banks will collapse in the next six months.

The people of Mongolia need the government to find a middle-ground on the investment climate that renews the energy behind foreign investment before such a crisis occurs.

What to watch, back on the record

Mr. D. Zorigt, the previous Minister of Mining under the last government said during his panel discussion at the Mongolia Investment Summit that there were four signals to watch for the foreign investment climate in Mongolia:

- Watch the big projects (e.g. Oyu Tolgoi) for signals from the government on the friendliness of the business environment.

- Watch progress on railway infrastructure projects.

- Watch progress on how the government will proceed with SEFIL.

- Watch progress on power plant 5 (the new power plant planned for Mongolia's capital Ulaanbaatar).

An important point he raised vis-a-vis the Dutch Disease that Christopher de Gruben opened the conference with is that "the projects in the country are larger than the [current] economy." In other words, the money being invested in projects in the country cumulatively is larger than Mongolia's current GDP.

From this list of four things to watch, we have already discussed in this article that the relationship with Oyu Tolgoi is testy and that the government is proceeding with SEFIL without amendment at this time. Thus, the other two items to question to gauge progress according to Mr. Zorigt are rail infrastructure and power plant 5.

Dr. Hancock later mentioned in his individual presentation on Erdenes Tavan Tolgoi that Mongolia Mining Corporation has already commenced work on its rail link to China while other rail projects in the South Gobi region where Mongolia Mining Corporation, Oyu Tolgoi, and Erdenes Tavan Tolgoi are all situated have still not moved past planning stages (see page titled Infrastructure Update in Dr. Hancock's presentation).

On Day 2 of the conference, Mr. B. Byambasaikhan, CEO of local conglomerate Newcom Group, discussed progress at the new power plant in his presentation. On the slide numbered 2, he discussed Power Plant 5 in Ulaanbaatar (locally called CHP5). Although past headlines have suggested construction of this power plant would already start by now, Mr. Byambasaikahn noted that the newly elected government's planning commission was now considering changing the physical site of the power plant (moving it from the west side of Ulaanbaatar, to the east side), thus creating the need to redo some plans before commencement. In other words, Mr. Byambasaikhan did not use, the project is delayed. Mr. Byambasaikhan also noted this plant will be the "biggest non-mining investment in Mongolia."

Currently, the arrow is pointing down on all four of Mr. Zorigt's signals to watch.

Why bother with Mongolia then?

Jim Dwyer, Executive Director of the Business Council of Mongolia, opened the conference by stating that there are still between $1 trillion and $2 trillion in natural resources in the ground in Mongolia. I took out a calculator and rounded Mongolia's population up to 3 million people. At the low end, $1 trillion, that would be over $330,000 in natural resources in the ground for every citizen of the country.

He was followed by Chuluunbaatar Ochirbat, Vice Minister at the Ministry of Economic Development who in the first key-note speech of the conference explained that GDP growth of 11% to 12% in Mongolia was a "crisis" because GDP growth should be 18% to 20%. With Mongolia's GDP coming from a tremendously low base, and with so much in natural resource wealth suddenly coming into production from Oyu Tolgoi, Erdenes Tavan Tolgoi, and many other mines, this is a reasonable statement.

James Polson, co-founder of A.I.D.D., a mining services company in Mongolia and Kazakhstan recited in his presentation that only 1% of Mongolian land is licensed to be mined and only 14.9% has been licensed for exploration. The potential opportunity remaining in this resource rich country is vast, and predominantly undiscovered.

(click to enlarge)

Source: A.I.D.D. presentation at Mongolia Investment Summit 2012

The last two images I will leave you with are maps of the world that are:

1) adjusted to represent population

2) adjusted to represent resource consumption

Notice in both that Mongolia is the small sliver just north of China (and just south of Russia; Mongolia is there between them if you enlarge the maps). Consider that Mongolia with at least $330,000 in natural resources in the ground for every man, woman, and child, resides next to the country emerging as a global leader in resource consumption (CHINA). Then, it is easily understandable why the potential of Mongolia, if the government can guide it well, is tremendous.

(click to enlarge)

World Map By Population. Source: WorldMapper.org Total Population

(click to enlarge)

World Map By Consumption. Source: WorldMapper.org Ecological Footprint

seekingalpha.com
Jon Springer

Comments

  1. If you are getting ready to move and you are starting to make plans to hire moving services in Tucson Tax Preparation Services Once you have located a few nearby moving companies that look promising.

    ReplyDelete
  2. hey there, your site is cheap. We do thank you for work
    Fathers Day Pics and Quotes

    ReplyDelete
  3. Greetings! Very helpful advice within this article! It's the little changes which will make the most important changes. Thanks for sharing! best nfl prediction sites

    ReplyDelete
  4. You are a very persuasive writer. I can see this in your article. You have a way of writing compelling information that sparks much interest. Happy Friendship Day Songs In English

    ReplyDelete
  5. An impressive share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was simply doing small analysis with this. And the man in reality bought me breakfast because I discovered it for him.. smile. So permit me to reword that: Thnx with the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending plenty of time to go over this, I am strongly concerning this and love reading much more about this topic. If at all possible, as you become expertise, do you mind updating your website with an increase of details? It really is extremely helpful for me. Huge thumb up because of this post!
    Some genuinely nice stuff on this internet site , I it.
    UNBLOCKED GAMES TANK TROUBLE

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have been reading out many of your articles and i can claim pretty nice stuff. I will make sure to bookmark your blog. happy birthday happy birthday bro birthday wishes gaming laptops best gaming laptop

    ReplyDelete
  7. I’m curious to find out what blog system you happen to be utilizing? I’m experiencing some minor security problems with my latest site and I’d like to find something more secure. Do you have any solutions?
    tambayan pinoy

    ReplyDelete
  8. Just now you can branch out from your daily understanding. Don’t give up your morals for anything. This will lead to a sad and unfulfilling life. Palm Sunday Songs

    ReplyDelete
  9. Recent research indicates probable weight control benefits by decreasing refined carbohydrate consumption Mothers Day Essay

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is something I actually have to try and do a lot of analysis into, thanks for the post Jokes Available here

    ReplyDelete
  11. If circumstances require you to seek payday loans, it is important to know how loans work you will have to pay exorbitant rates of interest. Sometimes the interest rate can calculate out to over 200 percent. There are legal loopholes employed to charge these extreme rates.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The mobile phone is a significant and indispensable communication tool for small entrepreneurs. convert money can be useful when following up with suppliers and customers, or when communicating with employees, and a way to make their small business accessible to their potential customers.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Credit control is important in a business especially for small businesses. This means that every small business should ensure that it collects its outstanding invoices. Some small businesses let their uncollected invoices accumulate which ultimately affects their cash flow and also the performance of the general business. maxon cinema 4d download

    ReplyDelete
  14. Someone essentially lend a hand to make critically articles I’d state. That is the first time I frequented your website page and so far? I amazed with the research you made to create this actual post extraordinary. Wonderful activity! where to buy solidworks

    ReplyDelete
  15. Good blog! I truly love how it is simple on my eyes and the data are well written. I’m wondering how I could be notified when a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your feed which must do the trick! Have a great day! 먹튀플러스

    ReplyDelete
  16. Once I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now each time a remark is added I get four emails with the identical comment. Is there any way you can take away me from that service? Thanks! 먹튀

    ReplyDelete
  17. True crypto VoIP renders a VoIP call completely impermeable to third parties. But is such a mechanism even possible for calls that go outside the network? trade bitcoin

    ReplyDelete
  18. Scientific works in the theories of finances and credit, according to the specification of the research object, are characterized to be many-sided and many-leveled. The definition of totality of the economical relations formed in the process of formation, distribution and usage of finances, as money sources is widely spread. For example, in "the general theory of finances" there are two definitions of finances: Trading криптовалюта

    ReplyDelete
  19. Have you ever wondered if blogging should be referred to as a business? A lot of people have treated their blogs as a casual project or past time that should not be given proper attention and care. Blogging requires investment in the form of time, money and energy. Since in most cases, it yields regular income, it should be treated as a profitable business and so must be handled with the mindset of a businessman. best bitcoin faucets

    ReplyDelete
  20. Is it actually possible to get ' creative ' when considering a franchise finance business loan for you new Canadian role as an entrepreneur in franchise financing? There are some tried and trusted rules we use in the franchise lending area, but a little creativity has never hurt anyone we believe! If you haven't considered how to finance your new business in the franchise industry then we feel it's probably a little too late in some ways, as your ability to finance your business properly we think has a lot to do with the ultimate growth and success of... i need $1000 loan today from UnitedFinances.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. When we are trying to understand Personal Finance, the best thing to do is to understand what Personal Finance is NOT. Many people think that accounting and personal finance are the same, but Personal Finance is NOT Accounting. On the surface they may seem the same; they both have something to do with money. تداول العملات

    ReplyDelete
  22. Is it actually possible to get ' creative ' when considering a franchise finance business loan for you new Canadian role as an entrepreneur in franchise financing? There are some tried and trusted rules we use in the franchise lending area, but a little creativity has never hurt anyone we believe! If you haven't considered how to finance your new business in the franchise industry then we feel it's probably a little too late in some ways, as your ability to finance your business properly we think has a lot to do with the ultimate growth and success of... refinance auto loans

    ReplyDelete
  23. Mining rigs for sale with worldwide delivery. We are a team of professionals with experience in Blockchain Management, Offline Sales, and Asic miner for sale Mining. Innosilicon g32 grin miner and best miner for lyra2rev2. As experts in Asic mining rigs for sale, we are specialists in reselling Antminer hardware since 2017! We exclusively sell products of the manufacturer and brand Bitmain so we can offer you great service and the best online pricing. ibelink, ibelink Asic, ibelink bm-k1, bitmain antminer s13 pro, bitcoin miners.

    ReplyDelete
  24. When we are trying to understand Personal Finance, the best thing to do is to understand what Personal Finance is NOT. Many people think that accounting and personal finance are the same, but Personal Finance is NOT Accounting. On the surface they may seem the same; they both have something to do with money. Crypto news

    ReplyDelete
  25. Howdy, i scan your blog sometimes and that i own the same one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam comments? If so how do you forestall it, any plugin or anything you’ll be able to advise? i buy abundant lately its driving me mad so any assistance is very much appreciated. seo and backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  26. If you want to start a business from scratch and are lacking experience in that specific industry then this article is for you to read. Find out the most comprehensive details about starting a fresh business without any experience at all. berita sumut terkini

    ReplyDelete
  27. With the current World economic chaos caused by Covid, Crypto-based E-Commerce systems will present a much faster and safer form of using one's assets, especially if they can be converted to Gold, and stored digitally. Also, by cutting out the Bank's fees, and then using AI systems to trade your assets overnight, will be a brilliant way of growing your assets. Better still, if you acquire V999 crypto Tokens, and trade them overnight, you can create a residual income from a %age of every Transaction fees. If you hold the generic ownership of these tokens, you get paid by other Traders, who, after acquiring your Tokens via a successful Trade, every time they trade using your Tokens. This could build up a Residual income, not just in your lifetime, but for your dependants. Crypto trading bot

    ReplyDelete
  28. Starting a small business or a home-based business is not something that should be entered into lightly. More often than not you'll go through a long period languishing while trying to make your business viable 9ja news

    ReplyDelete
  29. Everyone has heard how mymonero app and other crypto currencies have made millionaires of those who bought as recently as a year ago. Gains of 1,000% or more are not just possible, they have been common place with many of these crypto currencies.

    ReplyDelete
  30. This article discusses how to cut through the ICO Crowdsale hype and how to purchase real ICOs of value in the fledgling crypto revolution. In a world driven by hype and FOMO [Fear Of Missing Out], it is becoming clearer every day that a diligent crypto enthusiast needs to have a litmus test for picking a token to support in a world where genuine viable projects are hard to find and good projects with long term prospects are even harder to distinguish from money grabbing 'shitcoins'. eurs stablecoin

    ReplyDelete
  31. First of all, the Settlers of Catan game by Mayfair Games is a break-away, best selling game for a very good reason. It is just perfect for family play because nobody gets eliminated. And the players that are behind are still playing but they can pursue different goals. It is a very easy game to learn how to play. It is a strategy game that again, is very family friendly (important!). Card games

    ReplyDelete
  32. Boost workplace security and efficiency with Invigilo's cutting-edge Manufacturing Safety Videos - safeguard your team, protect your success!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Elevate your wellbeing the natural way - Buy Kratom Amazing Botanicals from Kratom Point. Unlock the wonders of nature's bounty with our premium kratom products. Discover the power of botanicals today.

    ReplyDelete
  34. "Discover a world of vitality with Botanic Tonic – Your journey to renewed energy starts at Kratom Point."

    ReplyDelete
  35. "Embark on an unforgettable journey with Karatom Point and uncover the mysteries of storytelling, like ahappy hippo dancing through the pages!"

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog